Year |
Player |
Sport |
| 2025 | Jaedyn Thibedeau | Women's Soccer |
| 2025 | Jackson Dempster | Men's Volleyball/Men's Basketball |
| 2024 | Nalani Galindo | Women's Water Polo |
| 2024 | Takoma Rosaria | Men's Basketball |
| 2023 | Charlie Gehler | Men's Basketball |
| 2023 | Karolina Borjas | Women's Soccer |
| 2023 | Rylie Hage | Women's Water Polo |
| 2022 | Samdrea Hsu | Women's Volleyball |
| 2022 | Jakob Milling | Men's Basketball |
| 2022 | Jack LeDuff | Men's Volleyball |
| 2021 | Aaliyah Theos | Women's Water Polo |
| 2021 | Cameron Barry | Men's Basketball |
| 2019 | Sophie Underwood | Women's Soccer |
| 2019 | Sirex Vasquez | Men's Volleyball |
| 2018 | Maria Andreyev | Women's Soccer |
| 2018 | Blake Seits | Men's Basketball |
| 2017 | Natalia Tsepina | Women's Soccer |
| 2017 | Dallas Haupt | Men's Basketball |
| 2016 | Katie Maddox | Women's Soccer |
| 2016 | Levi Vermeulen | Men's Volleyball |
| 2015 | Kelsie Telson | Women's Water Polo |
| 2015 | Brice Robell | Men's Basketball |
| 2014 | Hayden Kelley | Women's Soccer |
| 2014 | Drew Peterson | Men's Basketball |